Select a Year
| Place | Contestant | Points | Winner |
| 1 | Chris J 1 | 111 | Louisville |
| 2 | The Ides of Mel | 108 | Louisville |
| 3 | CBO3 | 107 | Michigan |
| 4 | MHerv1 | 106 | Michigan |
| 5 | Ryan Tarchalski | 104 | Louisville |
| 6 | Dunking With Dukey | 104 | Duke |
| 7 | SRC 2 | 102 | Louisville |
| 8 | Karl - 5 | 101 | Louisville |
| 9 | Jamie Stern1 | 101 | Louisville |
| 10 | Butterfly | 101 | Louisville |
| 11 | Why Pick Michigan? | 101 | Michigan |
| 12 | Toe Joe #3 | 100 | Louisville |
| 13 | RomanK | 99 | Louisville |
| 14 | Matt Hiltz | 99 | Louisville |
| 15 | MichMan2 | 99 | Louisville |
| 16 | PHIMU96 | 99 | Louisville |
| 17 | DP850 | 99 | Louisville |
| 18 | Beau | 99 | Michigan |
| 19 | chippewa Jeff | 98 | Louisville |
| 20 | rayman2 | 98 | Louisville |
| 21 | CBO1 | 97 | Louisville |
| 22 | Gonzaga Gone Zag Me | 97 | Gonzaga |
| 23 | jonnyc1 | 96 | Louisville |
| 24 | Brackavatnas | 96 | Louisville |
| 25 | I like tacos 1 | 96 | Michigan |
| 26 | Manti Te'o | 95 | Louisville |
| 26 | TEAM_DFS | 95 | Louisville |
| 28 | LOUGLU | 95 | Louisville |
| 29 | Labs/Auzzy | 95 | Indiana |
| 30 | HeBeGB | 94 | Louisville |
| 30 | JimH | 94 | Louisville |
| 30 | Nirup | 94 | Louisville |
| 33 | LOUGLU2 | 94 | Louisville |
| 33 | will crawford1 | 94 | Louisville |
| 35 | J Brohl | 94 | Louisville |
| 36 | OTTOmatic | 93 | Louisville |
| 37 | the whip | 93 | Louisville |
| 38 | Kristy2 | 93 | Louisville |
| 39 | Marissa Proebsting | 93 | Louisville |
| 40 | Jmuney | 92 | Louisville |
| 41 | CBO2 | 92 | Louisville |
| 42 | Ian Anthony | 92 | Michigan |
| 43 | SBUNNY2 | 91 | Louisville |
| 44 | Windsordave #1 | 91 | Louisville |
| 45 | howdon | 91 | Miami |
| 46 | PEG | 91 | Kansas |
| 47 | Courtney | 90 | Louisville |
| 48 | will | 90 | Louisville |
| 49 | Matt J2 | 90 | Indiana |
| 50 | Toe Joe #1 | 89 | Louisville |
| 51 | iceberg1 | 89 | Louisville |
| 52 | G-Money (2) | 88 | Louisville |
| 53 | Dad-mootz | 88 | Louisville |
| 53 | Mattt M2 | 88 | Louisville |
| 55 | Karl-1 | 88 | Louisville |
| 56 | Jeff Urbanski | 88 | Louisville |
| 57 | caden c | 88 | Michigan |
| 58 | Eric Goetsch #2 | 88 | Florida |
| 58 | Klinski1 | 88 | Miami |
| 60 | Mateo23 | 88 | Florida |
| 61 | Hot Wheels 3 | 88 | Duke |
| 62 | Jerry C | 87 | Louisville |
| 63 | Klinski2 | 87 | Michigan |
| 64 | Schmize | 87 | Florida |
| 65 | Dam | 87 | Indiana |
| 66 | wolverine | 87 | Miami |
| 67 | A Mason | 87 | Miami |
| 68 | Karl-2 | 87 | Indiana |
| 69 | mojodoc | 87 | Ohio St |
| 70 | Fox, Drew | 87 | Kansas |
| 71 | Tasti | 86 | Louisville |
| 72 | bjc 843 | 86 | Louisville |
| 73 | The Maestro | 86 | Louisville |
| 74 | Bruce Parkes | 86 | Louisville |
| 74 | KEB | 86 | Louisville |
| 76 | Hoby Klutch | 86 | Louisville |
| 77 | Fox, Elly | 85 | Louisville |
| 78 | l taylo2 | 85 | Louisville |
| 79 | KHarris | 85 | Michigan |
| 80 | Peeps2 | 85 | Indiana |
| 81 | Wings14 | 85 | Indiana |
| 82 | FlyingIllini13 | 85 | Miami |
| 83 | iceberg2 | 85 | Indiana |
| 84 | Rookalator | 84 | Louisville |
| 85 | That guy 3 | 84 | Louisville |
| 86 | Sam Hunt | 84 | Indiana |
| 87 | John Collier | 84 | Kansas |
| 88 | James Renaud | 84 | Indiana |
| 89 | Chris lane | 84 | Kansas |
| 90 | Matt Mason | 84 | Miami |
| 91 | Holly | 83 | Kansas |
| 92 | dcharron | 83 | Miami |
| 92 | l taylo | 83 | Kansas |
| 94 | Toots | 83 | Indiana |
| 95 | Belly Boo | 83 | Kansas |
| 96 | C$ | 82 | Indiana |
| 97 | Chris J 3 | 82 | Miami |
| 98 | Big Ten Dreamer | 82 | Michigan St |
| 99 | baby d | 82 | Duke |
| 100 | SBUNNY | 82 | Indiana |
| 101 | Phil Dunfy | 82 | Miami |
| 102 | ACC Slappy | 82 | Miami |
| 103 | Mike Pinkerton | 81 | Louisville |
| 104 | Payton | 81 | Louisville |
| 105 | JSL1 | 81 | Indiana |
| 106 | Bubba | 81 | Kansas |
| 107 | Bow Down | 81 | Kansas |
| 107 | dcharron2 | 81 | Miami |
| 109 | The Cooler | 81 | Indiana |
| 110 | Jeremy Suydam | 81 | Michigan |
| 110 | Rocky Wiltsey | 81 | Miami |
| 112 | Chippewa- JZ | 81 | Indiana |
| 113 | That guy 2 | 81 | Ohio St |
| 114 | Chez 2 | 80 | Louisville |
| 115 | Jamie Lytle 3 | 80 | Michigan St |
| 116 | RNDeluxe2 | 80 | Michigan St |
| 117 | Lover 07 | 79 | Michigan |
| 118 | Morning Glow | 79 | Indiana |
| 119 | Hefty | 79 | Indiana |
| 120 | Mike Roudabush | 79 | Kansas |
| 121 | MichMan1 | 79 | Miami |
| 122 | Cindy BRZ | 79 | Ohio St |
| 123 | KIMBO #1 | 79 | Miami |
| 124 | 2000 STING | 78 | Louisville |
| 125 | Eric Goetsch #1 | 78 | Louisville |
| 126 | CMC$ | 78 | Ohio St |
| 127 | drew renaud | 78 | Michigan |
| 128 | Jeff Luke | 78 | Indiana |
| 128 | will2 | 78 | Michigan |
| 130 | Dan Inglish | 78 | Kansas |
| 131 | National Treasure | 78 | Florida |
| 132 | Shaun Navarro1 | 78 | Miami |
| 133 | Kim M | 78 | Indiana |
| 134 | Just guessing | 78 | Duke |
| 135 | justin | 78 | Miami |
| 136 | ABUELO | 78 | Indiana |
| 137 | Flood | 77 | Louisville |
| 138 | chase c | 77 | Duke |
| 139 | Cheese | 77 | Indiana |
| 140 | Kristy1 | 77 | Gonzaga |
| 141 | Sciborski | 77 | Kansas |
| 142 | Jamie Lytle 1 | 77 | Duke |
| 143 | MaryBeth Mason | 77 | Gonzaga |
| 144 | Matt J1 | 77 | Michigan St |
| 145 | Fox, Sara | 77 | Miami |
| 146 | Chez 4 | 76 | Kansas |
| 146 | Troy Filipek | 76 | Florida |
| 148 | Bob Carlson | 76 | Miami |
| 149 | Kirk Freeman | 76 | Duke |
| 150 | jeff emery | 76 | Duke |
| 151 | bert | 76 | Kansas |
| 152 | windsordave #3 | 75 | Miami |
| 153 | Henrichs | 75 | Miami |
| 154 | grady | 75 | Michigan |
| 155 | DiCicco | 75 | Miami |
| 156 | THERVEY_1 | 75 | Ohio St |
| 157 | windsordave#2 | 74 | Kansas |
| 158 | Why NOT pick Mich.? | 74 | Michigan St |
| 159 | Gump | 74 | Gonzaga |
| 160 | Griffin Hamood | 74 | Duke |
| 160 | kbstmaarten | 74 | Indiana |
| 162 | Doug Proebsting | 74 | Wisconsin |
| 163 | Robert Kohn | 73 | Louisville |
| 164 | Berk44 | 73 | Miami |
| 165 | jjduke78 | 73 | Michigan |
| 166 | Carl Lite | 73 | Miami |
| 167 | Phil Ehardt | 73 | Indiana |
| 168 | Chez 3 | 73 | Kansas |
| 169 | Tim Kempen | 73 | Florida |
| 170 | DBeezy479 | 73 | Kansas |
| 171 | Nickew | 73 | Ohio St |
| 172 | Peeps | 72 | Michigan |
| 173 | Gash for Cash | 72 | Indiana |
| 174 | Jamie Lytle 5 | 72 | Indiana |
| 175 | RNDeluxe1 | 72 | Duke |
| 176 | zmadhungarian | 72 | Florida |
| 177 | wolverine II | 72 | Miami |
| 178 | rayman | 72 | Michigan St |
| 179 | Ryder Boy | 72 | Miami |
| 180 | Teddy | 71 | Indiana |
| 181 | Sharby | 71 | Kansas |
| 182 | STU | 71 | Indiana |
| 183 | 1captobvious | 71 | Wisconsin |
| 184 | German Shepards | 71 | Miami |
| 185 | RSDombrowski | 71 | Duke |
| 186 | black | 71 | Ohio St |
| 187 | E | 71 | Indiana |
| 188 | CWP | 71 | Indiana |
| 189 | Darth Gregor | 71 | Ohio St |
| 190 | MHerv2 | 71 | Duke |
| 191 | Baumann | 71 | Michigan St |
| 192 | Zack #3 | 71 | Georgetown |
| 193 | Dats13 | 70 | Ohio St |
| 193 | That guy 1 | 70 | Indiana |
| 195 | Tim Aaron | 70 | Indiana |
| 196 | kczar | 70 | Michigan St |
| 197 | Fun Funnel Freddie | 70 | Ohio St |
| 198 | Jamie Stern2 | 70 | Georgetown |
| 199 | Dr. O | 70 | Indiana |
| 200 | Judi | 70 | Indiana |
| 201 | OTTO | 69 | Kansas |
| 202 | Ethan Mau | 69 | Miami |
| 203 | Zack #4 | 69 | Miami |
| 204 | Chez 1 | 69 | Gonzaga |
| 205 | Matt J3 | 69 | Duke |
| 206 | Matt M1 | 69 | Miami |
| 207 | Fred Mau2 | 68 | Indiana |
| 208 | Fightin' Irish | 68 | Ohio St |
| 209 | I like tacos 2 | 68 | Florida |
| 210 | Canton | 68 | Indiana |
| 210 | MEATBALL | 68 | Kansas |
| 210 | Zack #2 | 68 | Indiana |
| 213 | Chris J 2 | 68 | Indiana |
| 214 | GoG'town | 67 | Georgetown |
| 215 | Nighttrain Lane | 67 | Florida |
| 216 | Ma-mootz | 67 | Indiana |
| 217 | SRC1 | 66 | Indiana |
| 218 | CamDuk | 66 | Duke |
| 218 | Hockey Sean | 66 | Kansas |
| 220 | The Window Man | 66 | Indiana |
| 220 | Train Wreckage | 66 | Kansas |
| 222 | chrislane2 | 66 | Indiana |
| 223 | G-Money (1) | 66 | Indiana |
| 224 | Who won?!?! | 66 | Miami |
| 225 | GB | 65 | Indiana |
| 226 | Bill Ziegler | 65 | Michigan St |
| 227 | windsordave#4 | 65 | Georgetown |
| 228 | Barbie 4 | 65 | Ohio St |
| 229 | Berg | 65 | Indiana |
| 230 | TimClark | 65 | Indiana |
| 231 | JasonW | 65 | Indiana |
| 231 | swoz | 65 | Duke |
| 233 | Tammy B | 65 | Ohio St |
| 234 | NoParity | 65 | Indiana |
| 235 | benchwarmers2 | 65 | Gonzaga |
| 235 | El Supremo | 65 | Duke |
| 237 | Zack #1 | 65 | Indiana |
| 238 | C. Brohl | 64 | Duke |
| 238 | FordTy | 64 | Georgetown |
| 240 | THERVEY_2 | 64 | Gonzaga |
| 241 | Eviscerator | 64 | Kansas |
| 241 | Toe Joe #2 | 64 | Indiana |
| 243 | NorMillion | 64 | Michigan St |
| 243 | will 3 | 64 | Indiana |
| 245 | Rharris | 63 | Indiana |
| 246 | Fox, Andy | 63 | Ohio St |
| 247 | Dan Inglish 2 | 63 | Duke |
| 248 | jonnyc2 | 63 | Kansas |
| 249 | Peeps3 | 62 | Kansas |
| 250 | JSL2 | 62 | Ohio St |
| 251 | Rastaman | 62 | Indiana |
| 252 | Hefty2 | 62 | Duke |
| 253 | Kyle McClone | 62 | Indiana |
| 254 | TPA | 61 | Indiana |
| 255 | T Bear | 61 | Michigan St |
| 256 | Dick Vitale | 61 | Michigan St |
| 257 | Shaun Navarro2 | 61 | Georgetown |
| 258 | GMONEY | 61 | Indiana |
| 259 | will crawford2 | 60 | Indiana |
| 260 | Eviscerator 2 | 60 | Michigan St |
| 261 | Dunk on your head | 60 | Indiana |
| 262 | JoCaine | 60 | Indiana |
| 263 | Glenn | 59 | Duke |
| 264 | 1papa | 59 | Duke |
| 264 | PKing | 59 | Indiana |
| 266 | Debi | 59 | Indiana |
| 267 | Justin2 | 59 | Ohio St |
| 268 | Czopes | 59 | Michigan St |
| 269 | Bruce Leroy | 59 | Ohio St |
| 270 | rayman3 | 59 | Kansas |
| 271 | schmize 1 | 59 | Miami |
| 272 | CRISHIZZLE | 58 | Indiana |
| 273 | OTTO1 | 58 | Kansas |
| 274 | Karl-3 | 58 | Ohio St |
| 275 | Queso | 58 | Indiana |
| 276 | BRZ | 58 | Michigan St |
| 277 | Sandra | 57 | Duke |
| 278 | EddieO | 57 | Indiana |
| 278 | Jim Nygord #1 | 57 | Michigan St |
| 280 | Jamie Lytle 2 | 56 | Michigan St |
| 281 | jojo | 56 | Kansas |
| 282 | Big Sexy | 56 | Michigan St |
| 282 | Krej Moe Dee | 56 | Indiana |
| 284 | Noonan | 55 | Wisconsin |
| 285 | El Supremo2 | 55 | Duke |
| 286 | Last one... | 55 | Kansas |
| 287 | benchwarmers1 | 55 | Duke |
| 288 | howdon2 | 54 | Duke |
| 289 | howdon1 | 54 | Indiana |
| 290 | Jim Nygord #3 | 54 | Michigan St |
| 291 | Mom Reimer | 53 | Gonzaga |
| 292 | Top Gun | 53 | North Caronlina |
| 293 | Fred Mau | 53 | Miami |
| 294 | GTATW | 52 | Georgetown |
| 295 | Karl-4 | 52 | Gonzaga |
| 296 | Noonan 2 | 52 | Michigan St |
| 297 | Jim Nygord #2 | 51 | Indiana |
| 298 | Jamie Lytle 4 | 48 | Georgetown |
| 299 | Jim Nygord#4 | 47 | Michigan St |
|
| 2024 | - | RU_READY2 |
| 2023 | - | MichMan2 |
| 2022 | - | Buzztroop |
| 2021 | - | Rain King |
| 2019 | - | Mr. Awesome #2 |
| 2018 | - | Dwill |
| 2017 | - | Abuelo |
| 2016 | - | Goetsch |
| 2015 | - | Donny Wells2 |
| 2014 | - | Kristen R |
| 2013 | - | Chris J 1 |
| 2012 | - | Andy Fox |
| 2011 | - | Train Wreckage |
| 2010 | - | Janet Balazs |
| 2009 | - | Rlaw22 |
| 2008 | - | SRC |
| 2007 | - | Dr Lask |
| 2006 | - | Silk |
| 2005 | - | Ryan Cull |
| 2004 | - | Andy Fox |
| 2003 | - | VanHyfte |
| 2002 | - | MichMan2 |
| 2001 | - | Big Sexy |
| 2000 | - | John Flood |
| 1999 | - | Steve Z |
| 1998 | - | Chez4 |
| 1997 | - | Jasmine M |
| 1996 | - | Goetsch |
| 1995 | - | Matt P. |
|